Game Pie with Mustard Mash

Game Pie with Mustard Mash

45 minutes prep, 40 minutes cook

Serves 5

Ingredients

2 mallard breasts, diced

4 jars confit mallard leg meat

2 pheasant breasts

2 pigeon breasts

4 white onions

Readymade puff pastry

1 pack chestnut mushrooms

1 tbsp redcurrant jelly

100g plain flour

400ml game stock

1 pack tender stem broccoli

Vegetable oil

For the mash:

1kg red skin potatoes

150ml milk

85g butter

1 tbsp wholegrain or Pommery mustard 

Salt

For the ale gravy:

1 bottle of any good ale

200ml game stock

4 tsps gravy granules

Method

Dice all the game except the mallard leg meat into 1-inch cubes. Coat the meat in seasoned flour and fry off until crisp and fully cooked. Place the meat in a pie dish.

Slice the onions and fry them in a little oil until softened. Add the mushrooms and, when golden brown, tip the mushrooms and onions over the top of the meat.

Heat up the game stock and add a little redcurrant jelly to sweeten before pouring over the pie mix. Leave the pie mix to cool and add the mallard leg meat.

Cover the whole pie dish with the pre-rolled pastry and brush the top with egg yolk. Bake for 40 minutes in an oven pre-heated to 180°C/Fan 160°C/Gas 4. 

While the pie’s in the oven, peel the red skin potatoes and boil until soft, then mash with the butter and milk. Add 1 tbsp of mustard, or more to taste. Season with salt and white pepper.

To make the gravy, pour the ale into a saucepan on a high heat and reduce it by half. Add the 200ml of game stock and thicken with the gravy granules.

Finally, prepare the broccoli. Rub oil into the broccoli then drop into a very hot pan. Sear until it begins to wilt and slightly blister.

Serve the pie as a centre piece alongside serving dishes of the mustard mash and broccoli. Finish with a big jug of your ale gravy.

Great British Food Awards
HOW TO ENTER

More recipes to try

Meera Sodha’s Miso Butter Greens Pasta
Main Light Bites Vegetarian
Meera Sodha’s Miso Butter Greens Pasta

10 minutes

Serves 4

Meera Sodha’s 18-Karat Laksa
Main Vegetarian Vegan
Meera Sodha’s 18-Karat Laksa

20 minutes

Serves 4

Meera Sodha’s Baked Butter Paneer
Main Vegetarian
Meera Sodha’s Baked Butter Paneer

15 minutes

Serves 4

Rosie MacKean’s Ham, Egg and Romesco Toasts
Starter Light Bites
Rosie MacKean’s Ham, Egg and Romesco Toasts

15

Serves 6

Falafel Scotch Egg
Falafel Scotch Egg

30 mins

Serves 10

Jon Watts’ Zesty Tiramisu Recipe
Pudding Puddings
Jon Watts’ Zesty Tiramisu Recipe

30 minutes

Serves 8

John Watts’ Gnocchi Cacio e Pepe Recipe
Main Lunch
John Watts’ Gnocchi Cacio e Pepe Recipe

5 minutes

Serves 2

Do Smoke’s Brilliant Bacon Bap Recipe
Breakfast Brunch
Do Smoke’s Brilliant Bacon Bap Recipe

5 days curing time plus ½ day smoking time 

Serves 3-4

Great British Food Awards
2026 AWARDS OPENING SOON
Tasting videos
3 of the best biscuit and tea pairings
3 of the best biscuit and tea pairings

Treat yourself by discovering three decadent ways to match award-winning biscuits with tea

How to cook perfect crispy bacon
How to cook perfect crispy bacon

Watch this if you're fed up with soggy bacon sandwiches